Weighing a Salary Increase Against a New Career Journey

You’ve informed your employer that you’re leaving the company, and they hit you with a counteroffer to get you to stay. It’s tough when this happens because often you’ll receive immediate benefits like a raise, but is it worth it? There are several factors to consider before you make your final decision, and you must choose wisely.

1. Weighing the Value of the Counteroffer

Employee discussing with manager
Image Credit: Shutterstock.

As you contemplate the counteroffer, delve into the specifics of the raise. Assess the percentage increase and how it aligns with industry standards and your contributions. Consider additional perks, such as bonuses, stock options, or enhanced benefits. Evaluate whether the raise reflects a genuine recognition of your skills and dedication, ensuring it meets your financial and professional expectations. Assess whether you’re familiar with the role and believe it fits you well.

2. Assessing Long-Term Career Goals

Bank Manager
Image Credit: Shutterstock.

You’ll also need to look past the immediate financial gain and consider your long-term career objectives. Does the current role offer a pathway to your desired career trajectory? Will you be able to develop the skills you need to get where you want to go? Are there leadership opportunities available? What’s the ceiling for overall advancement within the company? Once you answer these questions, take some time to analyze how a new opportunity might better align with your overarching career goals and ambitions.

3. Evaluating Current Job Satisfaction

Woman talking to coworker
Image Credit: Shutterstock.

You must reflect on your current job satisfaction and why you wanted to leave in the first place. For example, the raise would be the perfect remedy if it were just an issue of money. However, if it’s a problem with how you’re treated, it might not be worth staying. Assess your contentment with daily tasks and relationships with colleagues. If the counteroffer addresses salary concerns but not underlying job dissatisfaction, it may be worth exploring new opportunities that offer a more fulfilling work experience.

4. Company Culture

stressed man at work
Image Credit: Shutterstock.

Company culture plays a pivotal role in whether you stay or go. Examine how you genuinely feel about the existing company culture and if the counteroffer addresses any problems you want to be corrected. Reflect on your current work-life balance and stress levels. Consider how the counteroffer addresses factors contributing to job stress, such as workload, deadlines, or work hours. Weigh the impact on your overall well-being and personal life. Evaluate whether a new opportunity offers a more conducive work environment that aligns with your desired work-life balance. Protect your peace at all costs.

5. Comparing Benefits and Perks

Beautiful girl working talking in mobile
Image Credit: Shutterstock.

Beyond the salary, you need to scrutinize the overall benefits package. Look over the healthcare coverage, retirement plans, and additional perks your current employer offers. Compare these with the benefits provided by a prospective employer. Consider the tangible and intangible perks, such as flexible work arrangements, professional development opportunities, and wellness programs, to help you make an informed decision.

6. Written Agreement

Man talking to manager about job
Image Credit: Shutterstock.

Make sure you’ll receive everything you were promised should you stay. Request a written agreement that clearly outlines the terms of the counteroffer. Having a formal document ensures accountability and helps prevent misunderstandings in the future.

7. Workplace Dynamics

Co worker talking behind back
Image Credit: Shutterstock.

Your coworkers might react negatively if they discover your counteroffer. Feelings of resentment may arise if they perceive unequal treatment, potentially affecting teamwork and diminishing their allegiance to the company. To navigate this situation, maintain a professional demeanor and maintain some form of transparency with colleagues you have a relationship with.

8. Financial Implications

Matured old woman discussing with officer
Image Credit: Shutterstock.

While a raise is a significant factor, consider the overall financial implications. Will you get another raise in the future, or is this the plateau? Consider any accompanying changes in taxation, potential adjustments to benefits, and the long-term impact on your financial well-being. If you think you’ll be able to survive long-term on your new raise, then it’s worth considering. However, if you can make more money with the new company over time, and they have a similar benefits package to offer, you have to determine whether switching is the best option.

9. Future Employment Opportunities

Woman discussing with co worker
Image Credit: Shutterstock.

If you accepted an offer and then retracted your decision, it might reflect poorly on you if you decide to leave your employer for good and want to work for the company you ultimately rejected. The new employer could hesitate to hire you if they think you’re indecisive. Don’t make any hasty decisions, and inform your current and prospective employer of where you’re at in the decision-making process at every step. This gesture shows professionalism and can help ensure that some doors remain open for you in the future.

10. Factoring in Job Security and Stability

Man calculating tax
Image Credit: Shutterstock.

Assess the stability and security offered by the current position and the new opportunity. Examine each company’s financial health and make the best decision in alignment with your career goals. Consider recent layoffs, industry trends, and the overall economic landscape. Evaluate which option provides a more secure and stable foundation for your career, considering potential industry shifts and market conditions.

Avoid These 19 Pointless Expenses When Living Paycheck to Paycheck

Image Credit: Shutterstock.

Living from paycheck to paycheck puts one in a dangerous financial bind. It’s more prevalent than you can imagine. According to a survey by CNBC, more than half of all Americans (58%) live paycheck to paycheck. When money is tight, it’s crucial to pinpoint and cut out wasteful expenditures that eat away at your hard-earned savings.

Avoid These 19 Pointless Expenses When Living Paycheck to Paycheck

Author: Creshonda Smith

Title: Freelance Writer

Expertise: Entertainment, lifestyle topics like parenting, travel, and movies.


Creshonda is a content writer passionate about entertainment and lifestyle topics like parenting, travel, and movies. Hailing from Cleveland, OH, she graduated from The Ohio State University with a bachelor's and master's degree in Clinical Social Work. While she has specific topics that she enjoys writing about, she likes to tackle other topics that she's not as familiar with in an attempt to continually improve her writing skills and knowledge about the world around us. Creshonda has written for various publications such as MSN, Detroit Legal News, Jacksonville Journal-Courier, and more. When she's not serving as a Trending Topics writer for Wealth of Geeks, she's searching for tropical destinations to travel to with her family.